Traditional Balsamic Vinegar, 150 Years in the Making

Written By: The Planet D

When we were told that we’d be going learn how Traditional Balsamic Vinegar was made, I will admit, I wasn’t too excited. You see before going to Emilia Romagna in Italy, I didn’t have much of an appreciation for food.

traditional balsamic vinegar tour

We’ve tasted meals by some of the top chefs in the world, eaten at Michelin Star restaurants and dined in 5 star venues. While we loved the food, we never had an appreciation for the process. That all changed in Emilia Romagna.

Traditional Balsamic Vinegar

It was the people of the region who made us both fall in love with food. Food is a passion for Emilia Romagna and by spending three weeks in Bologna while doing day trips around the region, well we developed a passion for food as well.

tasting 100 year old balsamic vinegar
Dave loves traditional balsamic vinegar

Dave and I are more about the people when we travel. We can have the most expensive food, hotel room or seat in the house, but if the people aren’t interesting, well, who cares really?

The People Make The Experience in Emilia Romagna

In Emilia Romagna, it’s all about the people, so we cared very much! The food that they make and eat and taste, all have a history to it. Every place we visited had a story and every person we met had large, memorable personalities. The people of this region are people you’ll never forget.

And that is what it was like when we met the folks at family owned and operated Acetaia Pedroni in Rubbiara near the ancient town of Modena.

traditional balsamic vinegar barrels

This Balsamic producer is one of the oldest in the province, dating back to 1862. It has been operating for 150 years of uninterrupted service by the same family passed down through generations. And they are very proud of that distinction.

Traditional Balsamic Vinegar

The key word when talking about balsamic vinegar is “Traditional.” Traditional balsamic isn’t the typical vinegar you buy at Costco. This is like a fine wine.

It’s aged 12 to 45 years as it soaks in barrels over 150 years old. It’s so thick and delicious that bottles of Traditional Balsamic vinegar sell for up to $100 US for 100 ml.

most expensive vinegar | aged balsamic vinegar

Any other balsamic just isn’t the same. The true Aceto Balsamico Tradizionale needs to be aged a minimum of 12 years to be certified.

How Traditional Balsamic Vinegar Is Made

the process traditional balsamic vinegar
The Process of making traditional balsamic vinegar

The process of making balsamic vinegar is fascinating. It starts by picking the same grapes that are used for Lambrusco and Trebbiano grapes.

  • The first batch is made in October after grape harvesting.
  • The grapes are boiled and then the aging begins. 
  • The liquid is put in the largest barrel where it is left for a year.

It takes a minimum of 12 Years for Traditional Balsamic Vinegar to Age

After a year, the balsamic master comes back and moves a portion of vinegar from the large barrel into smaller barrels.

There are a series of 5 barrels of all different sizes, and the aged vinegar is moved each year from barrel to barrel, large to small. It’s a meticulous system, moving a small percentage of vinegar from one barrel to another until it reaches the final smallest cask which will eventually be aged enough to make the Aceto Balsamico Tradizionale.

This has to be a minimum of 12 years, but many are aged to 25 and even up to 45 years old. At 12 years though, the tasting begins.

Balsamic Vinegar Scoring System

aging barrels of balsamic vinegar

There are many rules and traditions and an expert taster comes to check the balsamic. There’s a complicated scoring system deciding on taste, texture/color, and nose.

The vinegar is scored out of total points of 200 and if they score too low, it all goes back in the barrel for at least another year. The process basically goes on forever.

Barrels are stained with ancient vinegar, and the deeper the color, the older the barrel. The vinegar soaks up all that good taste from decades past.

A lot of Work to make one small bottle of aged balsamic.

To make traditional balsamic, only 10% of the smallest barrel can be used. That’s one measly litre of balsamic! This balsamic maker is one of the largest in the area and when we asked them how many litres they make each year, we are told only 500.

It’s amazing that people have the patience for this. Something we noticed about this region of Italy though, is that everything is done with great passion and care.

Slow Food Movement

25 year old balsamic vinegar

Guiseppe, the grandfather of the operation was one of the first people involved in the Slow Food movement in Italy. His founding member plaque is displayed prominently in the dining room of his house.

It’s a movement created in the late ’80s to counter the fast food that was taking over the world at the time. By the looks of things in most places, fast food is the norm, but in Emilia Romagna, the movement stuck and in this region of Italy, it’s all about enjoying good eats in a relaxed and slow environment.

Tasting Aged Balsamic Vinegar

old balsamic vinegar tasting on ice cream

After our tour of the balsamic production, we had the chance to sample their efforts. Imagine our surprise when they put the 25 and 40-year-old bottles of balsamic on the table!

Proper traditional balsamic should never be cooked or mixed in dressing for salad. It is meant to be savoured and poured over your favourite foods. So we poured it over everything!

We had the 25 year balsamic poured over our tagliatelle and frittatas and the 40-year-old balsamic was poured over our gelato. Think balsamic and gelato won’t mix? Think again, it is a heavenly delight in your mouth!

balsamic vinegar of modena on pasta

Our favourite treat during our entire stay was to have aged balsamic vinegar drizzled over fresh Parmigiano-Reggiano (parmesan cheese for the English speakers out there) It is served everywhere at every meal.

Oh how we miss our chunks of delicious parmesan fresh from Parma with our aged balsamic from Modena. Can we go back to Bologna please?

The producers do make younger balsamic as well and these are the vinegar meant to be used in cooking and on your salads. We had chicken cooked in an 8 year balsamic and we had balsamic-infused pork as well.

traditional balsamic

Have you noticed something about this meal? There is no way it could possibly be eaten fast. With 5-courses, aged balsamic, bottles of Lambrusco (sparkling red wine of the region) you would never want to leave.

But then again, with Guiseppe entering every few minutes with a big smile on his face yelling, Andiamo, Andiamo! We got the hint that maybe we should be going.

But then again, I think that Pietro was just loving his little ongoing joke. The slow food guy telling the tourists to hurry up? That just made him laugh and laugh.

Travel Planning Resources

Looking to book your next trip? Why not use these resources that are tried and tested by yours truly.

Flights: Start planning your trip by finding the best flight deals on Skyscanner

Book your Hotel: Find the best prices on hotels with these two providers. If you are located in Europe use and if you are anywhere else use TripAdvisor

Find Apartment Rentals: You will find the cheapest prices on apartment rentals with VRBO

Travel Insurance: Don't leave home without it. Here is what we recommend:

  • Allianz - Occasional Travelers.
  • Medjet - Global air medical transport and travel security.

Need more help planning your trip? Make sure to check out our Resources Page where we highlight all the great companies that we trust when we are traveling.

About The Planet D

Dave Bouskill and Debra Corbeil are the owners and founders of The Planet D. After traveling to 115 countries, on all 7 continents over the past 13 years they have become one of the foremost experts in travel. Being recognized as top travel bloggers and influencers by the likes of Forbes Magazine, the Society of American Travel Writers and USA Today has allowed them to become leaders in their field.

Leave a Comment

9 thoughts on “Traditional Balsamic Vinegar, 150 Years in the Making”

  1. That is awesome that you got to try it on food. We went to a different producer during our Blogville week, but I was so surprised that she talked about putting it on gelato. I even asked about pairing it with chocolate and she recommended an oak barreled on. Of course, I can’t actually afford any of them, but even the (traditional) plastic spoon tastings were pretty good.

    Love that picture of the waterfall of barrels. That explains it really well.

    • Thanks Andrew, it’s sort of difficult to explain all the work that goes into making Traditional balsamic without going on and on forever, so the photo helps a lot to explain without having to go into too much detail. It’s amazing isn’t it, they have different barrels for different vinegars just like they do in wine. It’s quite the process.